Darren Criss & Jesse Tyler Ferguson Support Idina Menzel's New Broadway Show 'If/Then'!

Darren Criss is handsome while attending the opening night of If/Then held at the Richard Rodgers Theatre on Sunday (March 30) in New York City. The 27-year-old actor was joined by Jesse Tyler Ferguson, his husband Justin Mikita, Michael C. Hall, and his girlfriend Morgan Macgregor. PHOTOS: Check out the latest pics of Darren Criss